The first officer knocked firmly on the door of the corner house, but after a minute of silence with no answer, he sighed and jotted down a note in his pad.
"Look, Mr. Vance," the officer said, turning back to me. "I'll flag this for our evening shift. They can follow up when someone's actually home. Make sure you back up that video file."
I nodded, thanking him for his time, and walked back up to my house. The sun was dipping below the horizon, casting long, bruised shadows across the manicured lawns of Elm Street. As I reached my driveway, my next-door neighbor, Sarah, was pulling weeds from her flowerbed.
She looked up, wiping dirt from her forehead with the back of her gloved hand.
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
"Hey, Arthur," Sarah called out, standing up and dusting off her jeans. "Did I just see a police cruiser at your place? Everything okay?"
I stopped, letting out a frustrated breath. "Someone stole a package right off my porch twenty minutes after it was delivered. Caught the whole thing on my doorbell camera."
Sarah's eyes widened, and she let out a sharp, incredulous laugh. "Wait. Let me guess. Was it a guy in a gray hoodie? Tall, kind of shaggy hair, walks with a slight slouch?"
I froze. "As a matter of fact, yes. How did you know?"
Sarah crossed her arms, her expression hardening into pure annoyance. "Because he did the exact same thing to me three weeks ago. He walked right up, took my box of kitchenware, and walked away. When I caught him on my camera and marched over to his house to confront him, his sister answered the door, acted all confused, and miraculously 'found' my box sitting inside their hallway."
So I wasn't his first victim. Not by a long shot.
As we stood talking, another neighbor walking her dog overheard us and chimed in with a similar story about missing mail and suspicious loitering near her garage. The web was tightening, and the man in the gray hoodie was running out of plausible deniability.