I opened the front door just enough to keep the threshold clear, looking down at Clara and the plate of cookies she held out like a peace offering.
"Arthur," Clara said softly, offering a strained, fragile smile. "I just wanted to come by and thank you again for your incredible kindness the other night. You have no idea how much it means to our family that you didn't press formal charges against Julian."
I didn't take the cookies. I crossed my arms, leaning slightly against the doorframe. "Clara, let's be clear. I didn't press charges because the police recovered my property and issued a formal trespassing warning. That was a one-time grace period. If he comes near my house again, that grace is gone.
Clara's smile faltered for a fraction of a second, but she quickly recovered, her eyes glistening with manufactured moisture. "I know, I know. And we've talked to him, we really have. But... well, that's actually why I'm here. We wanted to ask you for a favor."
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
A favor. On my porch, after her brother had stolen from me.
"What kind of favor?" I asked, my voice flat.
"Well, the police warning is causing a lot of anxiety for Julian," she whispered, glancing nervously down the street as if the entire neighborhood were eavesdropping. "He feels like he's being hunted. We were hoping... since you got your package back unharmed... maybe you could call the precinct and ask them to clear the warning from his record? Just so he can feel safe walking around his own neighborhood again."
I stared at her in utter disbelief. The thief felt unsafe walking around the neighborhood he was victimizing?
"No, Clara," I said, my voice dropping an octave. "I will not be calling the police to clear his record. He stole from me, and according to my other neighbors, he's stolen from them too."
Clara's pleasant mask slipped completely, revealing a flash of cold entitlement.